The Daily News Online

Logout|My Dashboard
  • May 29, 2015

Online poll


Simmons sentenced to one year in jail for 2011 assault

Font Size:
Default font size
Larger font size

Posted: Monday, January 13, 2014 2:29 pm | Updated: 8:11 pm, Thu Jan 15, 2015.

BATAVIA — A judge as required by a higher court officially reduced the sentence for Jacquetta Simmons Monday in Genesee County Court.

“It was obvious the sentence I imposed I thought appropriate,” Judge Robert C. Noonan said. “I have no discretion to modify the sentence.”

Noonan then sentenced Simmons to one year in Genesee County Jail, with credit for time already served.

Simmons served about four weeks before she was released after a judge granted her a stay pending appeal. With good behavior, she could be released after about seven months.

Simmons was convicted Aug. 24, 2012, of second-degree assault for punching Wal-Mart cashier Grace Suozzi during an altercation in the checkout line on Christmas Eve, 2011.

The charge fell under the state’s Granny Law, making it a felony to cause any injury to a person 65 or older, providing the defendant is at least 10 years younger.

Suozzi was 70 and Simmons 26 at the time of the assault.

Noonan in November 2012 sentenced Simmons to a five-year prison term, with two years of post-release supervision.

Simmons’ attorneys immediately filed an appeal, claiming Noonan’s sentence was harsh and excessive, citing Simmons’ lack of criminal history and her community involvement. Simmons worked for city of Rochester parks programs, tutored children and worked for Generations Child and Elder Care, tending to infants and bringing them to the elderly.

At the time of the assault, Simmons was taking classes at Genesee Community College and worked with Literacy Volunteers.

The Appellate Court, Fourth Division agreed that the sentence was harsh and on Jan. 3 ruled that Simmons should be sentenced to one year in local jail.

Interestingly enough, Simmons will not be on any type of probation after her release from jail, something that is almost always imposed for a felony conviction.

Simmons has been free since posting $50,000 bail on Dec. 14, 2012.

She appeared in court accompanied by family.

Noonan asked her attorneys, Earl Key and Ann Nichols, if they wished to speak before sentencing.

They declined.

Noonan then asked Simmons.

Simmons stared ahead and said nothing before whispering to Key after about 15 seconds.

“She has nothing to say,” Key said.

“She’s not even willing to tell me herself that she has nothing to say?” Noonan asked.

Simmons quietly said “No.”

Noonan sentenced Simmons and then issued an order of protection for nine years. He said Simmons also must still pay about $2,500 restitution to Suozzi for medical bills.

Noonan asked Key whether he had any input as to how Simmons should pay restitution.

“We intend to appeal so you can set restitution payments for whatever,” Key said.

“You don’t want to be heard on what the installments will be?” Noonan asked.

Key reiterated that he is appealing so Noonan set payments at $100 a month beginning in February.

Simmons was escorted by a deputy out of court to be processed at Genesee County Jail. She will likely serve her time at Orleans County Jail, since Genesee does not house women inmates.

Previous story:

BATAVIA — A city woman was formally sentenced to one year in jail Monday afternoon in Genesee County Court.

Jacquetta Simmons received the sentence for punching a 70-year-old cashier in the face on Dec. 24, 2011, at the Wal-Mart store in Batavia.

Judge Robert Noonan imposed sentence during Monday's court session.

Noonan had originally sentenced Simmons to a five-year determinate sentence in state prison on Dec. 14, 2012, after a jury found her guilty of second-degree assault under the state's ‘‘Granny Law.’’

Simmons' defense attorneys immediately filed an appeal of Noonan's sentence, calling it ''harsh and excessive'' because of Simmons' lack of criminal history and her standing in the community.

The sentence was stayed pending appeal.

Earlier this month, a state appeals court unanimously agreed ''in the interest of justice'' to reduce Simmons' sentence to one year in jail.

She likely will serve much less time than that.

More to come.

  • Discuss

Rules of Conduct

  • 1 Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language. PLEASE TURN OFF YOUR CAPS LOCK.
  • 2 Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
  • 3 Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
  • 4 Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
  • 5 Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
  • 6 Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness acounts, the history behind an article.

Welcome to the discussion.


  • The Voice posted at 6:42 pm on Tue, Jan 14, 2014.

    The Voice Posts: 29

    Again... This is a VIOLENT FELONY which the sentence guidelines clearly state sentencing can be 2-7 years in Stae Prison. She pretty much got a back rub courtesy of the appeals court. A Non Violent Class D Felony can be punishable by No Jail/Proobation or 1-3 to 7 years time. Sorry, but the lady that can not return to work at Wal*Mart is victimized once again. Judge Noonan was more than fair in his original sentence of 5 years. SIMMONS can't even give respect to show an ounce of remourse???? Who is going to pay for the appeal? Probably Tax payers... Regardless, I often ask myself how defense attorney's can sleep at night. Poor Criminals getting a harsh sentence....Mean Judges!! I say do the crime do the time..PERIOD!

  • Interested Observer posted at 12:29 pm on Tue, Jan 14, 2014.

    Interested Observer Posts: 189

    "Interestingly enough, Simmons will not be on any type of probation after her release from jail,..."

    "Interestingly enough.." Journalism served with a side order of snark.

  • ebujack posted at 9:10 am on Tue, Jan 14, 2014.

    ebujack Posts: 229

    @mepot....for the same reason she had it in the first place.

  • former batavian posted at 7:00 am on Tue, Jan 14, 2014.

    former batavian Posts: 54

    LOL! early release for "good behavior". what a joke. Wasn't there anyone to assault in jail/prison? someone stole items from my home ($50000.+) and was ordered to pay restitution when she was released from prison. She was released several months early (18 mo sentence) and when I inquired about restitution was told "she doesn't have to make restitution, she chose to stay in prison longer to avoid probation after her release, so she doesn't have to pay". The criminals are given breaks for "good behavior" after committing crimes and the law-abiding citizens get screwed again.

  • mepot posted at 11:17 pm on Mon, Jan 13, 2014.

    mepot Posts: 1170

    Why would she be bringing her baby to court?

  • mepot posted at 5:55 pm on Mon, Jan 13, 2014.

    mepot Posts: 1170

    when does she report to jail?....they should of took her away immediately..

  • fiona48 posted at 5:38 pm on Mon, Jan 13, 2014.

    fiona48 Posts: 45

    this makes me so upset nothing like beating an elderly person and basically getting away with it.[angry]

  • mrchucknorris posted at 4:36 pm on Mon, Jan 13, 2014.

    mrchucknorris Posts: 131

    Total bs. Justice was not served in this case.

  • Tex posted at 3:29 pm on Mon, Jan 13, 2014.

    Tex Posts: 2

    In addition to this physical assault, Amway has financially assaulted 10s of millions of people:


Local Weather